As the family gathered around for our weekly game night, I couldn’t help but feel my eyes wander to my little step-sister, Molly. She was now 18 and a stunning blonde teen, flaunting her petite frame in her glasses and tight college T-shirt. Who knew that this innocent-looking girl would end up being the one to ignite a passion within me?
As we played Never Have I Ever, our family’s tradition of sharing our deepest secrets, Molly surprised everyone by revealing she’d never given a blowjob before. The room was silent for a moment, until Alex, my step-brother and her boyfriend, spoke up and offered to help her out. Little did he know that his kind gesture would soon be stolen by me.
As we continued the game, it became clear that Molly had more secrets up her sleeve. She’d never had sex in missionary position before – another opportunity for Alex to step in, or so I thought. But as they headed upstairs to "help" each other out, I couldn’t shake off the feeling that something was brewing between us.
As I watched them disappear into the night, I found myself replaying all the times we’d spent together, from family gatherings to impromptu gaming sessions. The way she’d tease me with her tiny shorts and tight tank tops, and how I’d sneak glances at her perky breasts whenever I could. It was a slow burn, one that had been simmering for years.
I made my move when the house grew quiet, slipping up to Molly’s room as stealthily as a predator stalking its prey. Her eyes widened in surprise as I pushed open the door, but any fear or uncertainty vanished the moment she saw the bulge in my pants – a big cock eager to unleash its pent-up desire.
As we began our secret game, there was no holding back. We ravished each other, our passion a fiery blaze that left us both breathless and craving more. It was as if we’d been playing this game all along, only nobody knew the rules except for us.
And so, on that fateful night, I stole not just the game from Alex but also the heart of my step-sister, leaving our family’s Never Have I Ever tradition forever changed.
Website: KingTube – The Hub of Erotic American Stories
